Caroline's Cafe
The venue's menu states 'Many items can be prepared gluten free' and that 'attention to allergy food preparation is diligent and detailed', but there is no dedicated gluten-free kitchen, no dedicated fryer, no marked menu, and no accreditation.
Per-allergen evidence
The venue's menu states 'Many items can be prepared gluten free' and that 'attention to allergy food preparation is diligent and detailed', but there is no dedicated gluten-free kitchen, no dedicated fryer, no marked menu, and no accreditation. The menu lists items like Conch Fritters, Tex-Mex Rolls, and sandwiches on buns that contain gluten, indicating a shared kitchen. No independent coeliac reviews or reports were found in the provided sources.
[1] Official Drink Menu - Caroline's Cafe, Caroline's Cafe (official menu)
Drink menu only; no allergen markings or dietary info.fetched May 17, 2026[2] Verified blog Home Caroline's Cafe, carolinescafe.com
The homepage describes the venue as a Key West cafe since 1999. It does not contain allergen or dietary information.fetched May 17, 2026[3] Verified blog Main Menu - Caroline's Cafe, carolinescafe.com
The main menu states that many items can be prepared gluten free and that attention to allergy food preparation is diligent and detailed, but it does not include per-dish allergen markings.fetched May 17, 2026Always confirm with venue staff before ordering. Tiers and accreditations are guides, not guarantees.
Read the methodology →