FreeFromFinder/ eat safely with references
Back to listings

SearchVaraderoIslamorada

Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar restaurant in Islamorada
Glenn hood · Google Places

Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar

The official menu does not mark GF items. Multiple FindMeGlutenFree reviews report GF items were previously marked but have since been removed, and that the kitchen uses shared fryers. One symptomatic coeliac diner reported no reaction after grilled fish and lobster tails, but another reported getting sick. Staff knowledge is inconsistent. No dedicated GF kitchen or fryer.

Address96 Madeira Rd, Islamorada, FL 33036, USA
CuisineSeafood
Price€€
Hours
Mon7:00 AM to 9:00 PM
Tue7:00 AM to 9:00 PM
Wed7:00 AM to 9:00 PM
Thu7:00 AM to 9:00 PM
Fri7:00 AM to 10:00 PM
Sat7:00 AM to 10:00 PM
Sun7:00 AM to 9:00 PM
Websiteloreleicabanabar.com/
Last verified

Per-allergen evidence

Coeliac · Gluten-free

confidence 0.65 ·

Marked menu, shared, Allergen-marked menu and aware staff but shared fryer / prep. Cross-contamination risk acknowledged.

The official menu does not mark GF items. Multiple FindMeGlutenFree reviews report GF items were previously marked but have since been removed, and that the kitchen uses shared fryers. One symptomatic coeliac diner reported no reaction after grilled fish and lobster tails, but another reported getting sick. Staff knowledge is inconsistent. No dedicated GF kitchen or fryer.

Pescatarian

confidence 0.50 ·

Marked menu, shared, Allergen-marked menu and aware staff but shared fryer / prep. Cross-contamination risk acknowledged.

The menu has many seafood and vegetarian options suitable for pescatarians, but no dedicated pescatarian menu or markings. Shared kitchen with meat. Pescatarian options are clearly available but not specifically marked.

Vegan

confidence 0.40 ·

Available on request, No marked menu but staff will accommodate. Quality varies by who is working that shift.

No vegan-specific menu or markings on the official menu. A single 6-year-old FindMeGlutenFree review mentions 'vegan options' but provides no detail. No dedicated vegan kitchen or protocols. Vegan options would be available on request only.

Vegetarian

confidence 0.40 ·

Available on request, No marked menu but staff will accommodate. Quality varies by who is working that shift.

No vegetarian-specific menu or markings on the official menu. The menu includes some vegetarian items (salads, mac & cheese, veggie sides) but no dedicated prep or protocols. Vegetarian options available on request.

Nut-free

confidence 0.30 ·

Available on request, No marked menu but staff will accommodate. Quality varies by who is working that shift.

No nut-free menu or markings on the official menu. The menu includes walnuts (Spinach Salad) and other potential nut ingredients. No dedicated nut-free kitchen or protocols. Accommodation would be on request only.

Dairy-free

confidence 0.30 ·

Available on request, No marked menu but staff will accommodate. Quality varies by who is working that shift.

No dairy-free menu or markings on the official menu. The menu is heavy on cheese, butter, and cream-based items. No dedicated dairy-free kitchen or protocols. Accommodation would be on request only.

Egg-free

confidence 0.30 ·

Available on request, No marked menu but staff will accommodate. Quality varies by who is working that shift.

Soy-free

confidence 0.30 ·

Available on request, No marked menu but staff will accommodate. Quality varies by who is working that shift.

No soy-free menu or markings on the official menu. The menu includes soy sauce (Tuna Nachos, Peppercorn Crusted Tuna) and other potential soy ingredients. No dedicated soy-free kitchen or protocols. Accommodation would be on request only.

Shellfish-free

confidence 0.30 ·

Available on request, No marked menu but staff will accommodate. Quality varies by who is working that shift.

No shellfish-free menu or markings on the official menu. The menu is heavily seafood-focused with many shellfish items. No dedicated shellfish-free kitchen or protocols. Accommodation would be on request only.

Low-FODMAP

confidence 0.20 ·

Available on request, No marked menu but staff will accommodate. Quality varies by who is working that shift.

No low-FODMAP menu or markings. The menu includes many high-FODMAP ingredients (onion, garlic, wheat, dairy). Accommodation would be on request only with no guarantee of safety.

Keto

confidence 0.30 ·

Available on request, No marked menu but staff will accommodate. Quality varies by who is working that shift.

No keto-specific menu or markings. The menu includes some keto-friendly items (grilled fish, steak, salads) but also many high-carb items. Accommodation would be on request only.

Kosher

confidence 0.30 ·

Not appropriate, Documented unsafe, multiple negative reports, or refuses to accommodate. Surfaced to warn rather than recommend.

Reminder

Always confirm with venue staff before ordering. Tiers and accreditations are guides, not guarantees.

Read the methodology →