The Mill Boardwalk Bar Brick Oven Pizza
The menu explicitly marks vegetarian pizzas, and a vegetarian option can be made vegan by removing cheese.
Per-allergen evidence
The menu explicitly marks vegetarian pizzas, and a vegetarian option can be made vegan by removing cheese. The kitchen is shared, with the same oven used for all items, which is typical for a pizza venue. Vegetarian diners should have no difficulty ordering.
[1] Verified blog The Mill Boardwalk Bar & Brick Oven Pizza - St Croix Business Guide, mystcroix.vi
The business guide listing categorizes the restaurant under Gluten-Free Friendly, Vegan, and Vegetarian tags. It does not provide any specific practice details.fetched May 31, 2026[2] Aggregator THE MILL BOARDWALK BAR BRICK OVEN PIZZA, Christiansted - Reviews, TripAdvisor
TripAdvisor page with venue's own About text and menu; confirms GF pizzas cooked in shared oven, marks vegetarian, vegan, and nut (Margherita).fetched May 31, 2026One menu item (Margherita pizza) is explicitly marked as containing nuts, but no other nut information is provided and no kitchen practices for nut cross-contact are documented. Call ahead to confirm whether a nut-free meal is feasible.
Gluten-free pizza bases are available but are cooked in the same oven as wheat-containing pizzas, creating a high cross-contact risk. Multiple independent sources report this shared-oven setup. One reviewer who ordered both gluten-free and vegan was served a burnt pizza and advised against combining dietary requests. The venue is not suitable for coeliac diners.
[1] Verified blog Untitled, visitusvi.com
The tourism directory listing notes that the venue claims to offer gluten-free options, and the listing itself carries vegetarian and gluten-free tags.fetched May 31, 2026[2] Verified blog The Mill Boardwalk Bar Brick Oven Pizza, stcroixscuba.com
A dive shop blog post mentions gluten-free delights and anti-pizza options.fetched May 31, 2026[3] Verified blog The Mill Boardwalk Bar & Brick Oven Pizza - St Croix Business Guide, mystcroix.vi
The business guide listing categorizes the restaurant under Gluten-Free Friendly, Vegan, and Vegetarian tags. It does not provide any specific practice details.fetched May 31, 2026[4] Aggregator THE MILL BOARDWALK BAR BRICK OVEN PIZZA, Christiansted - Reviews, TripAdvisor
TripAdvisor page with venue's own About text and menu; confirms GF pizzas cooked in shared oven, marks vegetarian, vegan, and nut (Margherita).fetched May 31, 2026The venue offers a vegan option by removing cheese from pizzas, but the same shared oven is used and a reviewer who ordered both gluten-free and vegan reported a poor result, advising against combining dietary requests. No dedicated vegan preparation or equipment is available.
[1] Verified blog The Mill Boardwalk Bar & Brick Oven Pizza - St Croix Business Guide, mystcroix.vi
The business guide listing categorizes the restaurant under Gluten-Free Friendly, Vegan, and Vegetarian tags. It does not provide any specific practice details.fetched May 31, 2026[2] Aggregator THE MILL BOARDWALK BAR BRICK OVEN PIZZA, Christiansted - Reviews, TripAdvisor
TripAdvisor page with venue's own About text and menu; confirms GF pizzas cooked in shared oven, marks vegetarian, vegan, and nut (Margherita).fetched May 31, 2026Always confirm with venue staff before ordering. Tiers and accreditations are guides, not guarantees.
Read the methodology →