FreeFromFinder/ eat safely with references
Back to listings

SearchMelbourne183 Elgin St

Gemma Simply Italian restaurant in 183 Elgin St
Gemma Simply Italian · Google Places

Gemma Simply Italian

Venue's own website and online ordering menu indicate GF options with marked items. FindMeGlutenFree confirms GF items (gnocchi, pasta) are marked on the menu but explicitly states the establishment is NOT a dedicated gluten-free facility. Multiple symptomatic coeliac reviewers report no symptoms, but GF pizza is unavailable and cross-contamination risk exists in shared kitchen.

Address183 Elgin St, Carlton VIC 3053, Australia
CuisinePizza · Vegan · Vegetarian · Italian
Price€€
Hours
Mon5:00 to 10:00 PM
TueClosed
Wed5:00 to 10:00 PM
Thu5:00 to 10:00 PM
Fri5:00 to 10:00 PM
Sat5:00 to 10:00 PM
Sun5:00 to 10:00 PM
Websitewww.gemmasimplyitalian.com.au/
Last verified

Per-allergen evidence

Coeliac · Gluten-free

confidence 0.70 ·

Marked menu, shared, Allergen-marked menu and aware staff but shared fryer / prep. Cross-contamination risk acknowledged.

Venue's own website and online ordering menu indicate GF options with marked items. FindMeGlutenFree confirms GF items (gnocchi, pasta) are marked on the menu but explicitly states the establishment is NOT a dedicated gluten-free facility. Multiple symptomatic coeliac reviewers report no symptoms, but GF pizza is unavailable and cross-contamination risk exists in shared kitchen.

✓ marked menu

Cited references

[1] blogPizza and Gnocchi Bar in Carlton, Lygon Street - Gemma Simply Italian , gemmasimplyitalian.com.auVenue homepage: 'Neapolitan Pizzas. Homemade Gnocchi. Vegan and GF Options.' Links to dining PDF menu.fetched 2026-05-13[2] aggregatorGemma Simply Italian - Pizza & Gnocchi Bar - Gluten-Free Italian Restaurant in Carlton , FindMeGlutenFreeFMGF listing: reported GF menu, GF items marked (gnocchi, pasta). NOT dedicated GF. Positive coeliac reviews. Warning about cross-contamination.fetched 2026-05-15[3] blogPizza and Gnocchi Bar in Carlton, Lygon Street - Gemma Simply Italian , gemmasimplyitalian.com.auDuplicate venue homepage: 'Neapolitan Pizzas. Homemade Gnocchi. Vegan and GF Options.'fetched 2026-05-15[4] blogGemma Simply Italian , gsi.kposordering.com.auOnline ordering menu with items labeled Veg/Vegan; 'Gnocchi Puttanesca (Vegan)' explicitly marked 'Homemade gluten free gnocchi'.fetched 2026-05-15

Vegan

confidence 0.60 ·

Marked menu, shared, Allergen-marked menu and aware staff but shared fryer / prep. Cross-contamination risk acknowledged.

Venue website promotes 'Vegan and GF Options'. Online ordering menu clearly marks several items as Vegan (Gnocchi Puttanesca, Penne Arrabiatta, Pizza alla Romana). No evidence of dedicated vegan prep area or fryer; shared kitchen with shared equipment.

✓ marked menu

Vegetarian

confidence 0.50 ·

Marked menu, shared, Allergen-marked menu and aware staff but shared fryer / prep. Cross-contamination risk acknowledged.

Online ordering menu marks multiple items as Veg (vegetarian), including various pasta, pizza, and salad options. No dedicated vegetarian kitchen; shared kitchen.

✓ marked menu

Reminder

Always confirm with venue staff before ordering. Tiers and accreditations are guides, not guarantees.

Read the methodology →